This comment was offered by Reza Aslan, controversial sociologist of religion and host of Believer.
So do we accept that belief as manifested in world religions is, for Aslan, mostly equivalent to zealotry – the shadow side of every religion? The claws of zealotry pierce the heart of religion once its spirit has been relegated to the oppression of others via a blinkered way of seeing the divine totality in lived life.
The zealotry of Pinhas is rewarded with a brit shalom (covenant of peace) and the priesthood after he publicly spears Zimri, the Simeonite prince, and his paramour, Cozbi, the Midianite princess. Following a census of the people, Moses divides the Land of Israel by lottery among the Israelite tribes, and then transitions leadership to Joshua, who will lead the people into the Promised Land. Rightful inheritance for women is championed by the five daughters of Zelophehad, who petition Moses for justice.
Commitment to reaching out in good will through intentional interreligious dialogue is also important. While it is important to remain vigilant “to insist on freedom of religion and freedom from religion for everyone in the land,” recall how the dangers of “anti-fundamentalism” are lurking just around that corner. As American Jews, it is our democratic responsibility to be “holding elected officials, religious leaders, and political pundits accountable” as a most “important way to take citizenship seriously and model for the world the best of what participatory democracy can look like in a very diverse society.”
The challenge remains, of course – how to imagine a world where humans will evolve through its religions, enabling a world where zealotry against the other dissolves into a brit shalom, a devotional responsibility for others.
– Rabbi Aubrey Glazer
Artwork note: This week’s illustration is an abstract depiction of the five daughters of Zelophehad. “The daughters of Zelophehad…stood before Moses and before Eleazar the kohen and before the chieftains and the entire congregation at the entrance to the Tent of Meeting.” (Numbers 27:1–2) These sisters are often championed as proto-feminists because they “opened the future for all women.” Here, their five figures emerge from the ground – going against the grain. Illustration by Christopher Orev Reiger.